Using Classified Ads to Learn about Henry Stark’s Real Estate

My 3rd great-uncle Henry Stark (1832-1910) was born in December 1832 in Rathkeale, County Limerick, Ireland. His father died in December 1851 and nearly the entire family immigrated to Darien, Fairfield County, Connecticut, two years later, about 1853. Henry was 21 years old at that time.

Illustration: Superior Courthouse, Bridgeport, Connecticut
Illustration: Superior Courthouse, Bridgeport, Connecticut. Source: CT

That same year ground was broken for a new Superior Courthouse in Bridgeport, Connecticut. Seven years later Henry Stark was naturalized at that Superior Court, on 30 March 1859 – and one year after that,  Abraham Lincoln spoke there on 10 March 1860.

Henry lived his life in Fairfield County, Connecticut – so I looked in GenealogyBank’s Historical Newspaper Archives to see what more I could learn about him.

Both “Henry” and “Stark” are common names, so I began looking for Henry by narrowing my search to Connecticut newspapers.

A screenshot of GenealogyBank's search page showing a search for Henry Stark
Source: GenealogyBank

This search found two classified ads that told me a little bit more about my great-uncle.

According to this 1900 classified newspaper ad, Henry was selling a four-room cottage in nearby Noroton Heights for $600.

A real estate ad, Stamford Advocate newspaper advertisement 8 November 1900
Source: GenealogyBank, Stamford Advocate (Stamford, Connecticut), 8 November 1900, page 5

No street address is given – but I knew that the family had lived in the Noroton section of Darien since the 1860s.

A few years later, in 1904, Henry was renting out a “modern” seven-room house on “Gardener Street” in Noroton Heights for $15 a month.

A real estate ad, Stamford Advocate newspaepr advertisement 12 May 1904
Source: GenealogyBank, Stamford Advocate (Stamford, Connecticut), 12 May 1904, page 5

$15 a month – that seems pretty cheap!

Was that a typical rent price for the New York metropolitan area in the early 20th century? I did a bit of Googling to find out.

The New York Tenement Museum gives us something to compare Henry’s rent price to:

“As Jared Day notes in Urban Castles (1999), his history of tenement landlords in New York City, written leases did not become standard until the 1920s, so we have few written records for what any tenement residents paid in rent before that decade… Although we don’t have leases, we do have Lawrence Veiller, a 19th century housing reformer. For his groundbreaking exhibit about tenement housing, he recorded the rent paid by every family living on the block bounded by Canal, Bayard, Chrystie, and Forsyth Streets in 1900. According to his records, a three-room apartment on the first floor of a tenement rented for $12-$13/month (about $4/room), while the same apartment on the 4th floor rented for $9.50-$10/month (about $3/room).”

–Source: “The Rent Is Due: A History of Rent at 97 Orchard Street,” Tenement Museum

While we would expect New York City apartment rent to be a bit higher than rent in nearby Darien, Connecticut – comparatively, $15 a month for an entire seven-room house seems pretty reasonable.

Contrast that with this 5-bedroom, 2-bath home for sale on Maple Street just a few homes over from Gardiner Street in Darien right now.

Photo: a house in Darien, Connecticut

According to Zillow, this home was built in 1898. Who knows, maybe it is similar in look and style to the 7-room home that Henry was renting out in 1904.

Genealogy Tip: Classified ads can be a great way to learn more about your relatives and the local economy at the time they lived. Start searching for them at

4 thoughts on “Using Classified Ads to Learn about Henry Stark’s Real Estate

  1. Lincoln was never a U.S. senator (and, for that matter, he was never a state senator, either). He was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives in 1846 and served one term. He was defeated by Stephen A. Douglas in the 1858 Senate election. He ran for president in 1860.

    1. Hi Penny –
      You are so right – Finding the stories of our ancestors and relatives is really powerful.
      Very few family stories are passed down – newspapers are our treasure house of these details – waiting to be found.

      These discoveries can change your entire picture of who they were and the lives they lived.
      I find new details about them every day.

      Thank you for writing,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.