Thanksgiving Means Turkey! Or Does It?

Introduction: In this article, Gena Philibert-Ortega searches old newspapers to find some delicious recipes to help you add variety to your Thanksgiving feast this year. Gena is a genealogist and author of the book “From the Family Kitchen.”

It’s that time of the year: the annual Thanksgiving feast. While turkey typically takes pride of place on the dinner table, it’s not everyone’s favorite meat. Do you have family members who wave off the turkey platter? Are you tired of serving turkey? What can you serve instead? Historical newspapers provide some great ideas for alternatives.

Pork: The Other White Meat

One substitute for turkey is pork. Glazed ham is a family holiday favorite for many. This 2003 food column from Abilene, Texas, starts off with a Honey-Glazed Ham recipe submitted from a recipe by Cindy Stichert. She says of her recipe:

“This recipe for honey-glazed ham is sure to please even the pickiest ham lover. I make this every Thanksgiving, and my family loves it. It tastes much like the famous Honey Baked Ham but costs much less to make. You can even buy the ham pre-sliced to make it easier and more like the original.”

A ham recipe, Abilene Reporter-News newspaper 23 November 2003
Abilene Reporter-News (Abilene, Texas), 23 November 2003, page 56

If ham isn’t your favorite, you could try a pork roast. This 1958 recipe from Dallas, Texas, is for a Tropical Crown Pork Roast and includes instructions to give the butcher in cutting the roast. The recipe includes bacon, rice, and pineapple.

A pork roast recipe, Dallas Morning News newspaper 20 November 1958
Dallas Morning News (Dallas, Texas), 20 November 1958, page 3

Beef: The Other Option

Beef might be the preferred meat for your family table because of its flavor and how nicely it pairs with other Thanksgiving sides like mashed potatoes and gravy. Thanksgiving gives you the opportunity to dress it up a bit or to try a more expensive cut.

This 2018 recipe from Birmingham, Alabama, is definitely worthy as the centerpiece of a Thanksgiving dinner. Garlic Herb-Crusted Roast Beef has a fairly simple ingredient list. Fresh herbs and spices including basil, thyme and rosemary, garlic, salt and pepper are part of the crust.

A roast beef recipe, Birmingham News newspaper 7 December 2018
Birmingham News (Birmingham, Alabama), 7 December 2018, page 38

If you want to go all out for Thanksgiving, consider a prime rib. Another 2018 recipe from Birmingham, Alabama, provides directions for how to prepare this cut of beef and the accompanying horseradish side.

A prime rib recipe, Birmingham News newspaper 21 December 2018
Birmingham News (Birmingham, Alabama), 21 December 2018, page 36

For the Vegetarians in the Family

Maybe you want to avoid meat altogether or have other family members who do. What are some hearty vegetable dishes that can substitute for an entrée? Just preparing the same old vegetable sides won’t be enough. You’ll need to include some heartier entrée dishes as well.

Portobello mushrooms are a substantial dish. This 2006 stuffed portobello mushroom recipe from Staten Island, New York, is a good substitute. If there are vegans in the family, you could substitute the cheese with non-dairy cheese.

A mushroom recipe, Staten Island Advance newspaper 15 November 2006
Staten Island Advance (Staten Island, New York), 15 November 2006, page 45

A risotto dish might be the entrée you’re looking for. This 2011 Butternut Squash Risotto recipe from Richmond, Virginia, would be a good choice. Make sure to use vegetable broth with the risotto and to search for dairy-free ingredients if your dinner table includes a vegan.

A risotto recipe, Richmond Times-Dispatch newspaper 16 November 2011
Richmond Times-Dispatch (Richmond, Virginia), 16 November 2011, page 47

Search Tip: If you’re looking for vegetarian options in the newspaper, search for the word “Vegetarian” in the “Include these keywords” box on the GenealogyBank search page. You can also search for the word “Meatless.”

Happy Thanksgiving!

There’s something comforting in having the same meal year after year to celebrate. But there is nothing wrong with changing it up a bit. Consider your menu this year and what your family’s preferences are. There is still plenty of time to plan, and a collection of newspapers such as GenealogyBank’s Historical Newspaper Archives have some great recipes to try.

Explore over 330 years of newspapers and historical records in GenealogyBank. Discover your family story! Start a 7-Day Free Trial

Note on the header image: Happy Thanksgiving display.
Photo credit: https://depositphotos.com/home.html

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.