Site icon GenealogyBank Blog

Genealogy Mystery Solved: When Dates Don’t Agree, Double-Check Your Facts

a drawing of Sherlock Holmes

I found her!

Here in GenealogyBank’s Social Security Death Index (SSDI), I found the record for Marcia (Leavitt) Dyer.

She was born on 27 September 1880 and died on 15 May 1968.

But – Marcia Leavitt’s online family tree said she was born 31 March 1881. Why aren’t these records matching up with each other?

Were there two different Marcia Leavitts – born within months of each other? I needed to find out.

So I retraced the research others had done.

Look closely at her birth certificate. I think I’ve found the source of the confusion.

Source: FamilySearch

It doesn’t say that she was born on that date – it says her birth was “reported for year ending Mar. 31, 1881” – but no specific date was given. Some family historian had probably seen this record and entered that date on her family tree as her actual birth date.

Genealogy Tip: when you see dates on a family tree that don’t match what your own research has turned up, dig deeper, trying to find as many primary sources as you can, to solve the discrepancy.

Exit mobile version